Pros

  • The cookies have a great, rich taste with a soft and chewy texture that combines chocolate chips and Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup chunks for an indulgent experience.
  • Higuality chocolate and peanut butter cups add to the flavor and satisfaction.
  • They pair wonderfully with cold milk, enhancing the overall treat experience.
  • The flavor is welalanced, offering a nostalgic peanut-buttery twist that stands out among packaged cookies.
  • The cookies provide a satisfying snack that’s perfect for those craving a sweet, chocolateanut butter combo.
  • Despite being chewy, the texture is enjoyable and avoids an overly processed or artificial taste.
  • The product is available in a convenient family size, making it great for sharing or multiple snacking occasions.

Cons

  • Contains several highly processed ingredients like high fructose corn syrup, palm oil, artificial flavors, hydrogenated vegetable oils, and TBHQ preservatives, which may deter healtonscious buyers.
  • Cookies sometimes break when being removed from the packaging, especially the first in each row, due to tight packing.
  • Some find the cookies smaller than expected and the overall sweetness on the higher side.
  • May not be the best everyday snack due to the ingredient list and sweetness level.
  • A minority of users prefer the regular Chips Ahoy! cookies over this chewy, peanut butteilled version.
  • Not ideal if you’re avoiding synthetic additives or looking for alatural ingredients.

Bottom Line

Chips Ahoy! Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies with Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups deliver a delicious, indulgent peanut butter and chocolate experience with a soft, chewy texture that many cookie lovers will adore. However, if you’re wary of processed ingredients or want a less sweet option, this might be more of an occasional treat than a daily snack. For those who prioritize natural ingredients, or prefer a less rich cookie, exploring other classic Chips Ahoy! varieties might be worth considering.

Lowest at any Popular Retailer
$16.00 at Walmart

Where to Buy

Prices last updated: February 26th 2026 11:28 pm
Get ShopSavvy
ShopSavvy is totally free and works on all popular phones and browsers
Download ShopSavvy App

Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more

Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension

Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.

Latest Deals

🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️

a month ago
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️

a month ago